Q: Dear sheikh whats the Hanbali view about the size of the beard and what about praying in congregation behind an imam who has no beard or short one and the rulings about this?
A:
الحمد لله رب العالمين والصلاة والسلام على أشرف الأنبياء والمرسلين، سيدنا ونبينا محمد وعلى آله وصحبه أجمعين. وبعد:
Imam Ibn Muflih al-Hanbali (d. 763H) said: "The beard is to be left (untrimmed), and in accordance with the Madhhab (of Ahmad), so long as its length is not detestable (being exaggeratedly long). Hence, shaving it (to the skin) is Haram as mentioned by our Shaykh (Ibn Taymiyah). It is not considered disliked if one was to trim the excess hair that is a fist in length, also it is ok with trimming that which includes around the throat, and (all this mentioning of trimming to a fist length) was implemented by Ibn 'Omar." [Kitab al-Furua', Dar al-Kitab al-Arabi, Beirut, 1st ed, (2002) V.1/P.74]
As for the ruling of praying behind someone with no beard (to the skin), will depend on the reason to why he shaves, if shaving it was due to a certain political enforcement as which is unfortunately apparent in some Muslim lands, or shaved it due to a medical reason, then the prayer behind such a person as an Imam is excusable (only in these cases and others that are similar due to necessity). As for the one that has no excuse and shaves it on a regular basis, then as the Madhhab states from the apparent words of Ibn Muflih above it is Haram, also, due to
committing a prohibited action continuously is deemed a Fasiq in accordance with the Hanbali's, and furthermore, the prayer behind a Fasiq Imam is invalid in the Hanbali Madhhab too. Imam al-Buhouti (d. 1051H) said: "The Imamship of a Fasiq is invalid ... and a Fasiq is the one whom commits a major sin; thus, a major sin is that which is cosigned to a legal punishment in this life or has a warning for a punishment in the next life, and also (a Fasiq) is to be persistent in minor sins." [Kashaf al-Qinaa', DKI, Beirut, V.1/P.576-577]
Your question can be summarised in the following points:
1- The beard is more preferable to be left to flow and is permissible to trim any excess hair a fist in length.
2- The Imamship of one who shaves his beard to the skin on a regular basis with no excuse is a Fasiq, and his prayer or praying behind him is not excepted (invalid according to the Hanbali's).
والله اعلم.


